The risk I took for one teacher, and what it built years later.
There is a particular kind of quiet that settles over a school building when the person in charge of it has made fear the primary tool of leadership. Not loud fear. Not shouting or public humiliation. Just a steady, low-grade current that teaches everyone, without anyone saying it directly, to ask permission for things that should never have required permission in the first place.
I worked under a principal like that for a period of my career as an assistant principal, and I want to be honest about what it did to me before I tell you what happened on the day that changed everything. I became careful. Smaller. I began rehearsing conversations in my head before I had them, calculating which requests were worth the risk of her irritation and which were not. I told myself I was being strategic. Some of it was survival.
One afternoon, a teacher I supervised came to my office in a state I had not seen from her before. She was not just upset. She was barely able to get words out, her hands shaking as she tried to explain that her husband was having a medical emergency and she needed to leave campus immediately.
Her next sentence is the one I still remember clearly, years later. She asked me, through tears, whether I thought our principal would let her go.
I felt something harden in me in that moment, quickly, almost before I had time to think it through. Here was a woman whose husband might be in real danger, and her most pressing fear was not getting to him. It was whether leadership would grant her permission to be a human being first and an employee second.
I did not go ask permission. I told her to go, immediately, and that I would handle her classes for the rest of the day. I remember the relief on her face, and I remember, almost simultaneously, feeling my own stomach tighten with the calculation I had just made without fully deciding to make it.
What I did not expect was how the rest of that day would actually feel. I had two classes to teach with no lesson plans of my own, no preparation, no warning. I remember standing in front of her students, improvising, watching the clock, and feeling a strange, low-grade dread that had nothing to do with the teaching itself. I kept waiting for a knock on the door, an office call, some signal that word had already reached our principal and consequences were already forming.
Nothing came that period. Or the next. By the end of the day, I had taught four class periods that were not mine, exhausted in a way that had less to do with the actual work and more to do with the sustained bracing, the muscle of waiting for a reaction that never quite arrived.
✦ ✦ ✦
Subscribe to the Weekly Roundup
Every Friday, one email with the week's Leadership Behind the Scenes articles. A headline and a one-line synopsis for each, so you choose what to read and skip the rest. No daily inbox clutter. Just the stories worth your time, once a week.
✦ ✦ ✦
I want to be honest about the fear that showed up after she left, because it is easy, in hindsight, to make this sound braver than it felt in the moment. I knew our principal well enough to know that unilateral decisions, even reasonable, humane ones, were not always well received. I spent the rest of that afternoon half expecting a call, a comment, some form of consequence for having acted without checking in first.
It did not come that day. I do not fully know why. Maybe it never reached her. Maybe it did and she decided, for once, to let it go. I only know that I spent the day teaching four classes I had not planned for, watching the clock, genuinely unsure whether I had just done the right thing or the costly thing, and slowly coming to understand that in that building, those two things were not always the same.
Ministry had already taught me something years before that day, something I was not willing to unlearn for the sake of political safety in a school hallway. People matter more than programs. People matter more than protecting my own comfort with the person over me. I had said that principle out loud in sermons and staff trainings more times than I could count. That afternoon was the first time it actually cost me something to mean it.
Years passed. I moved on from that role, then from that district entirely, the way careers move, one door closing behind another. I genuinely forgot about that particular afternoon. It had not felt, at the time, like something worth remembering specifically. It felt like the only decision available to a person with a conscience.
Then, years later, that same teacher, now sitting in a district administrative role herself, called to interview me for a position I had applied for. I did not immediately connect her name to the memory. It was not until partway through the conversation, when she brought up that afternoon directly, that I understood why she had wanted to interview me herself instead of leaving it entirely to her hiring team.
She told me she had never forgotten that I covered her classes without hesitation, fully aware of what our principal might have said about it. In her memory, that decision had become evidence of exactly the kind of leader I actually was, not the polished version I might have presented in an interview, but the version that showed up when no one was auditioning for anything.
In my mind, I had simply done the right thing in a hard moment. In her memory, it had become the reason she trusted me enough to bring me into her next season, years later, in a role I did not even know I was auditioning for at the time.
I got that job. And I have thought, many times since, about how easily that afternoon could have gone the other way. I could have told her to wait. I could have gone looking for our principal first, calculating the safer, more procedurally correct move. Nothing about that choice would have looked unreasonable from the outside. It simply would not have been the choice that mattered years later, to the one person who was actually there to remember it.
Here is what I want every leader to sit with, especially the ones currently working under leadership that makes even reasonable decisions feel risky. You rarely know, in the moment, which small act of protection is quietly being recorded as evidence of who you actually are. The decision that costs you something with the person above you may be the exact decision that opens a door held by someone watching from below, a door you will not even know exists until years later, when it opens on its own.
I do not think that means every act of protection will be rewarded so neatly, or so visibly. Most of them probably will not be. But I have stopped believing that the invisible ones do not matter simply because no one calls to thank you for them years later. Some of them, I suspect, are simply quietly shaping who you become, whether or not anyone ever tells you so.
I think about that afternoon differently now than I did even a few years ago. At the time, it felt like a single decision, made quickly, under pressure. Looking back, I understand it was actually a test of something I did not know was being tested, whether the principle I preached about people mattering more than programs would survive contact with real professional risk, or whether it would quietly bend the first time it actually cost me something. It did not bend. I am grateful, now, that I found that out about myself in a moment that mattered, rather than simply assuming it would hold and never actually finding out.
-- Dr. Rhonda
The Next Step: If you are weighing a decision that could cost you politically but is right for your people, take The Close the Leadership Gap Diagnostic™. It is built to help you see where your instincts are already stronger than the fear telling you to play it safe.
Add comment
Comments